Best Mascaras Eyes Reviews & Guide

Our Top Picks for the Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

If you have sensitive eyes, using regular mascaras can lead to side effects, such as redness. Worse, it will look like you are crying all the time. To avoid this, choose one of the mascaras that are listed below.

1. Maybelline Makeup Full ‘n Soft Washable Mascara

Made by a popular and trusted drugstore makeup brand, this is an excellent choice if you are looking for a hypoallergenic mascara with a price that does not hurt the wallet. It contains Vitamin E, which is also the one that is responsible for its advanced thickening formula. Immediately after application, you will instantly notice how thicker your lashes are. The mascara is in a super saturated black shade, which is the perfect way for you to pull off a fierce look. The mascara also features Quick Dissolve System, an innovation that will make it easy to wash off. Best of all, you do not have to worry that it can irritate your sensitive eyes once it is rinsed.

Pros & Cons

  • Indeed, it washes off quite easily with warm water and cream cleanser.
  • It doesn’t clump and coats lashes evenly from root to tip.
  • It wears well throughout the day with minimal flaking.
  • It is sufficiently black.
  • It provides a very natural, defined look.
  • It’s neither particularly lengthening nor volumizing.
  • My lashes feel neither soft nor full after using the product.
  • Somehow I always manage to smear it on my upper lid, no matter how hard I try.


2. Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara

The brand name itself can already provide you with enough reason to have it considered over other products that are available on the market. It will help to achieve longer and stronger lashes without worrying about being harsh on sensitive eyes. To provide the nourishment needed by the lashes, it has a revolutionary list of ingredients, which include olive oil and Vitamin E. A lot of its users were all praises with regards to how long-lasting the mascara is. Plus, it is also not easily prone to flaking, smudging, and clumping, allowing it to last throughout the day.

3. Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Origin Nourishing Mascara

It is from a company that is known for its natural beauty products, so you can have peace of mind in choosing this mascara. The product comes with a 100% natural formula. It uses jojoba oil as one of its main ingredients. Combined with glycerin, it can effectively moisturize the lashes while making them look healthier. The convenient applicator is also a plus, making it a snap to put your mascara on. With this mascara, you can choose from two colors – classic black or classic brown, both of which are sure to bring out the best in your lashes.

4. Physicians Formula Organic Wear Jumbo Lash Mascara

With the 100% natural volumizing technology in this product, you can have peace of mind. It will moisturize and nourish your lashes without fear that it will result in irritation. It is approved even by ophthalmologists. The product is specifically labeled as hypoallergenic, providing an assurance that there are no ingredients that can lead to harsh side effects. Some of the natural ingredients that are utilized in this mascara include aloe leaf extract, olive leaf extract, soybean oil, carnauba wax, and orange fruit water, among others. It is also a good thing that it comes with an eco-brush that is 100% recyclable.

5. Naturally Rooted Premium Organic Mascara

It may not be from a brand that is as popular as those that have been mentioned above, but you can be confident that its quality will be second to none. It is 85% organic and does not contain harmful chemicals that can irritate the eyes. It does not have gluten, dyes, fragrances, and parabens, among other ingredients that can trigger sensitivity. Instead, it uses natural components, such as chamomile and sunflower oil. The two are popular for their moisturizing benefits.  Lastly, the mascara comes in rich black color, making it the perfect choice if you would like to project a bold look.

6. Skin2Spirit Natural Mineral Mascara

This is another hypoallergenic mascara that should be on your radar if you have sensitive eyes. It will add thickness and length to your lashes while preventing the possibility of irritation every time it is applied. It has a formula that is hypoallergenic. Looking at the list of the ingredients, you will notice that it does not contain petroleum, lead, dye, and gluten, among others that could be harsh for people who have sensitive skin. You will also love the versatility of this product as it can double as an eyeliner.

7. EVXO Mineral Mascara

volume and length without the need to resort in using chemical-laden products. This mascara is living proof of such. It is cruelty-free and uses a distinct blend of natural ingredients. It is infused with coconut oil, which is a great way to keep the lashes healthy and hydrated. The jet black color of the mascara is also a good thing, which will make it an ideal choice for those who would like to stand out in the crowd. If you want a subtle look, you can apply only a thin layer.

8. Honeybee Gardens Truly Natural Mascara

Want to have silky and defined lashes? Then this product is another one that should be on your list! It is water-resistant. Despite the latter, you can be sure that it does not contain chemicals that are normally used to make mascaras last longer. It is made using ingredients that are certified organic. It is enriched with high-quality botanicals that can give life to your lashes without causing irritation in any way. A lot of its users were also happy with the easy and smooth application, making it a great choice for those who tend to be impatient when it comes to putting makeup on.

9. Marcelle Xtension Plus Mascara

This is a hypoallergenic and fragrance-free mascara that promises to add length and curl to your lashes in no time. There is a double-sided wand, which will make it great in terms of ease of application. It also does not clump, so you can be sure that it will look good on your eyes even if you have been wearing it the entire day. It is recognized even by the Canadian Dermatology Association, which is one thing that can provide you with peace of mind.

10. RevivaLabs Hypoallergenic Mascara

It has been praised by many users because it is a great lash builder for people with sensitive eyes. The mascara has fibers that will thicken and lengthen the lashes while looking natural. It is also tear-proof since it does not contain chemicals that can irritate the eyes during its application. With its gentle formula, it will be great even for people who are wearing contact lenses. Plus, it is made by a company that has almost five decades of experience in the industry, so you can be confident that their products are indeed reliable.

What to Look for in a Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

To make the right choice, below are some of the most important factors to consider:

  • Look at the Ingredients: As much as possible, look for those that are made using natural ingredients instead of toxic chemicals that could be harsh on the eyes.
  • Go Fragrance-Free: The mascara should also be fragrance-free. In most cases, chemicals are used to add fragrance to the mascara.
  • Choose Hypoallergenic: You need to look for one that is specifically labeled as hypoallergenic to have an assurance that it will be gentle on your sensitive eyes.
  • Avoid Waterproof: If the mascara is waterproof, certain chemicals might be used to make it longer-lasting, which can irritate the eyes.

Mascara for Sensitive Eyes FAQs

What are the Symptoms of Eye Sensitivity to Mascara?

This can vary from one individual to the other. Often, it will include having teary and itchy eyes. Also, your eyes can suffer from redness and can appear swollen once an allergic reaction has been triggered.

Which Ingredients Should be Avoided?

As a rule of thumb, you should avoid chemicals and preservatives as they are often the ones that cause irritation. Avoid those with toxic thickening ingredients, as well as artificial fragrances. Go for basic or simple ingredients if you want to have peace of mind.

How Do You Apply Mascara on Sensitive Eyes?

Do not apply directly to the roots of the lashes to avoid sensitivity. Brush it lightly on the ends and avoid direct contact to the skin. Using an eyelash curler will also be good to minimize the need to apply mascara.


In sum, not all mascaras are the same. They differ in many things, especially when it comes to the ingredients that are used. If you have sensitive eyes, you need to be careful when choosing what to use. Pay attention to the products that we have listed above to make a decision you won’t regret!

Leave a Comment